Data·Citizenan agentic layer over NYC Open Data
CatalogExploreAnalyticsMapAsk the agentFindingsGuideStatus
Data from NYC Open Data via the Socrata Discovery API. Quality scores are computed from a sample and are indicative, not authoritative.
← Catalog

NYC Open Data Help Desk: Data Questions and Reported Errors

r67x-e97rCity Government10 columns
This is a list of responses to public inquiries to the NYC Open Data Team via the Contact Us page on www.nyc.gov/opendata that get triaged as being “Data Questions” and “Reported Errors.”
View on NYC Open Data↗

Quality

A95.8 / 100

From a 500-row sample across 10 columns.

completeness99/ 25% weight
consistency85/ 20% weight
accuracy100/ 20% weight
timeliness100/ 15% weight
usability95/ 20% weight

Related datasets

  • NYC Open Data Help Desk: Public Dataset Requests0.52
    joins onassigned_agency
  • NYC Open Data Plan: Future Releases0.37
    joins onstatus
  • NYC Open Data Plan: FOIL Datasets0.35
  • NYC Open Data Plan: Website Data0.34
    joins onstatus
  • NYC Open Data Release Tracker0.31
  • Jobs NYC Postings0.31
  • NYC Open Data Plan: Mayor's Management Report (MMR) Indicators

Sample rows

inquiry_idinquiry_typeassigned_agencyinquirydataset_namedataset_urlassigned_agencys_responsestatusdate_submitteddata_as_of
13108Reported ErrorDepartment of Transportation (DOT)The link above leads to a public-facing presentation of the DOT Automated Bike Counter data. (It is an expanded view of the data presented on this page: https://www.nyc.gov/html/dot/html/bicyclists/bikestats.shtml.) I think there are errors in the calculations of the 2026 monthly counts, or else data were missing, and the daily averages were estimated from the remaining data. For example, the total traffic volume for September 2026 is given as 125,652 counts, and the daily average as 4654 counts, whereas 4654×30 would equal 139,620. Similarly, the total count for June was 127,177, and the daily average was 6056, but 6056×30 would be 181,680. Might you be able to explain these anomalies? If they do result from estimates substituting for missing data, it would be very helpful if the DOT put a note to that effect on the relevant pages. Many thanks for your assistance.

Columns

10 queryable · 10 profiled

The machine field names SoQL needs, with the publisher's own description of each.

FieldTypeDescriptionNullValues
inquiry_idtextThis inquiry's unique identification number0%12377120595601
inquiry_typecategoricalThe type of inquiry this is.0%Data QuestionReported Errorof 2
assigned_agencytextWhich City Agency is responsible for addressing this inquiry.0%Agency not assigned yet.Department of Buildings …Department of Finance (D…
inquirytextThe inquiry that was sent in by the user.0%No Inquiry Submitted

Query this from your own app

GET /api/datasets/r67x-e97r
GET /api/datasets/r67x-e97r/quality
GET /api/datasets/r67x-e97r/related
GET /api/columns?dataset=r67x-e97r
0.30
  • NYC Open Data Plan: Removals0.30
  • —
    https://newyorkcitydot.eco-counter.us/?search=ed+ko&year=2026&month=9
    Response not sent yet.
    Pending
    2026-10-09T00:00:00.000
    2026-10-09T00:00:00.000
    13107Data QuestionDepartment of Parks and Recreation (PARKS)Hello NYC Parks / NYC Open Data team, I am working with Forestry Tree Points (hn5i-inap, data last updated October 7, 2026) and have a question about the RiskRating column. Your data dictionary documents the Risk Assessments RiskRating as 3-12, "Combination of Failure, Impact Target, and Consequence" (each scored 1-4). In Forestry Tree Points, 72 rows carry a RiskRating below that range: 0 on 14 rows, 1 on 22 rows and 2 on 36 rows, with RiskRatingDate between 2017-02-24 and 2020-01-03. Examples (GlobalID, each rated 0, dated 2020-01-03): 154E6059-6C9A-403D-9048-1B9BF46DF6BD, 0B250E1A-801F-4843-A7A8-45BC9A0DD364, 090AE20D-95D5-4F76-8E73-9575A8377C7B. My questions: 1. What do ratings of 0, 1 and 2 mean - a placeholder, an earlier scale, or a data-entry error? Should they be treated as missing? 2. When one Level 2 inspection records several defects (several Risk Assessment rows), which total does the tree point's RiskRating keep - the highest, or another rule? In case it is useful: in Forestry Risk Assessments (259a-b6s7), RiskRating equals Failure + ImpactTarget + Consequence on 1,544,190 of the 1,544,207 rows that have all four values; 16 of the 17 exceptions have CreatedDate 2017-09-26. Thank you, ***Forestry Tree Pointshttps://data.cityofnewyork.us/d/hn5i-inapResponse not sent yet.Pending2026-10-08T00:00:00.0002026-10-09T00:00:00.000
    13103Data QuestionNew York City Fire Department (FDNY)Good morning, I am looking at these three datasets and had a few questions about how the information. 1. Does FDNY document how STARFIRE dispatch records relate to NYFIRS incident records? 2. Is there any documented connection between STARFIRE_INCIDENT_ID and IM_INCIDENT_KEY 3. Does BFI provide any identifier that links to either of those? 4. Does FDNY explain when a fire gets a BFI investigation? 5. Is there any official description of how dispatch records, incident reports, and BFI investigations relate? Thank you in advance for any answers you can provide or sources where I may find these answers. Sincerely, *** Fire Incident Dispatch Datahttps://data.cityofnewyork.us/d/8m42-w767Response not sent yet.Pending2026-10-08T00:00:00.0002026-10-09T00:00:00.000
    13100Data QuestionDepartment of Citywide Administrative Services (DCAS)It would be really helpful to other City agencies and potential job seekers if the Jurisdictional Classification and Incumbent Salary were included in this dataset, as it is germane to understanding which titles require a civil service exam and, for agency human capital, the potential impact of hiring an incumbent.NYC Civil Service Titleshttps://data.cityofnewyork.us/d/nzjr-3966Response not sent yet.Pending2026-10-07T00:00:00.0002026-10-09T00:00:00.000
    13098Data QuestionThe NYC Open Data TeamHello, 1. how can I tell what list is up to date or expired? 2. I see my name and the title of ***, next to an agency many times. I was only contacted by the New York law Department in 2023, and the NYCT also in 2023 regarding the *** position. Since my name is displayed several times next to an agency does that mean the agency tried to contact me? Civil Service List Certificationhttps://data.cityofnewyork.us/d/a9md-ynriWe are in receipt of your request. To ensure your inquiry is handled, please submit your request and any future list inquiries via the OASys contact page at https://NYC.gov/CivilServiceNowNYC.Closed2026-10-07T00:00:00.0002026-10-09T00:00:00.000
    13095Data QuestionDepartment of Buildings (DOB)Hello. I am writing an academic paper analyzing the emissions effects of NYC LL97 (and related policies) that was previously a part of my PhD dissertation. I have been using "NYC Building Energy and Water Data Disclosure for Local Law 84 2023 to Present (Data for Calendar Year 2022-Present)" and the previous vintages of this dataset back to 2012. I am close to finishing the paper, however, I need data for 2026 in order to complete my first draft (since one exemption group has until 2026 for first reporting). I know that the data will be updated on the website once it is ready, but I was wondering if you could possibly release the data to me prior to its public release for a short period of time. The reason is very simple: as a young, junior scholar, it is very easy for older and more senior scholars to steal my paper and publish it before me, even if I present the idea and publish the working paper first, making my last five years studying NYC climate policies result in no contribution to economics and climate policy debate around the world. It would be a huge break in my career if you would be willing to provide me exclusive access for a short period of time if possible prior to its public release. I would be happy to discuss more with your team and leadership, present my preliminary results, and of course credit NYC DOB as you prefer. If it's not possible to provide the data early, I would still be eager to present my results to the DOB and any other interested parties. Thank you for your consideration. Sincerely, *** NYC Building Energy and Water Data Disclosure for Local Law 84 2023 to Present (Data for Calendar Year 2022-Present)https://data.cityofnewyork.us/d/5zyy-y8amResponse not sent yet.Pending2026-10-05T00:00:00.0002026-10-09T00:00:00.000
    13091Reported ErrorNew York City Police Department (NYPD)It's missing a substantial incident: https://www.cbsnews.com/newyork/news/morris-park-fatal-crash/ that occurred on Halloween. Motor Vehicle Collisions - Crasheshttps://data.cityofnewyork.us/d/h9gi-nx95Response not sent yet.Pending2026-10-05T00:00:00.0002026-10-09T00:00:00.000
    13079Data QuestionOffice of Technology and Innovation (OTI)License confirmation: NYC Orthoimagery 2024/2022 tile service in a commercial app. Hello, I build ***, an app for NYC facade contractors. We display the NYC OTI Citywide Orthoimagery (2024 and 2022, 6-inch) as a roof texture in a 3D view of a single building, served from the public ArcGIS tile service above, with the credit "(c) City of New York - NYC OTI orthoimagery (CC BY 4.0)". The OTI metadata lists the imagery as CC BY 4.0, while the ArcGIS item links to the general NYC.gov Terms of Use. Could you confirm that use under CC BY 4.0 with that attribution is acceptable in a commercial application? We cache small crops per building and do not redistribute the full dataset. Thank you, ***—https://tiles.arcgis.com/tiles/yG5s3afENB5iO9fj/arcgis/rest/services/NYC_Orthos_2024/MapServer (also NYC_Orthos_2022)Per the Open Data Law (https://opendata.cityofnewyork.us/open-data-law/), users do not need a license in order to copy, reuse, or share the data on NYC Open Data. New York City's open data is free for anyone to use for any purpose they see fit. We do not require, but encourage users to cite the data. The ArcGIS assets have a similar license, and the credit you included is great. Our team would love to see the results of your analysis! Once they're done, please submit any project that uses NYC Open Data to be featured on our Project Gallery (https://opendata.cityofnewyork.us/projects/) via this submission form: https://opendata.cityofnewyork.us/project-submit/.Closed2026-10-01T00:00:00.0002026-10-09T00:00:00.000
    13078Data QuestionDepartment of Transportation (DOT)This is a follow-up on an inquiry I submitted yesterday evening, 13072. I have found the answers to the first two questions I asked. (Sorry, I'm new at this, and initially missed the fact that there were three tabs on the page that included the most recent bicycle counts, so I thought that the page didn't contain any data.) My questions 3 and 4 remain in force: In sum, the Queensboro Bridge entries are all classified as referring to bikes in the travelMode category. Does "bike" include all traffic crossing the shared bridge path or just motorized plus non-motorized bicycles?Bicycle and Pedestrian Countshttps://data.cityofnewyork.us/d/ct66-47atResponse not sent yet.Pending2026-10-01T00:00:00.0002026-10-09T00:00:00.000
    13074Data QuestionNew York City Fire Department (FDNY)This data (and other Fire incident data e.g. https://data.cityofnewyork.us/Public-Safety/Fire-Incident-Dispatch-Data/8m42-w767/) update very slowly (on the order of weeks to several months). Can they be made closer to real time?Bureau of Fire Investigations - Fire Causeshttps://data.cityofnewyork.us/d/ii3r-svjzResponse not sent yet.Pending2026-10-01T00:00:00.0002026-10-09T00:00:00.000
    Hello, I received your e…
    There are two rows for d…
    dataset_nametextThe name of the dataset associated with this inquiry.0%OATH Hearings Division C…311 Service Requests fro…DOB NOW: Build – Job App…
    dataset_urlurlThe URL of the dataset associated with this inquiry.0%No URL Submitted.https://data.cityofnewyo…https://data.cityofnewyo…
    assigned_agencys_responsetextThe response the assigned agency sent to the user.0%Response not sent yet.Thank you for bringing t…Thank you for bringing t…
    statuscategoricalThe status of this inquiry, in terms of where it is in the process of being responded to.0%ClosedPendingOpenof 3
    date_submitteddatetimeThe date that the user submitted this inquiry.0%2018-06-13T00:00:00.0002019-07-16T00:00:00.0002023-12-14T00:00:00.000
    data_as_ofdatetimeThe date in which the information in this record was last determined to be accurate.0%2026-10-09T00:00:00.000of 1